Tuesday, January 22, 2008

Law and Rhetoric

The Supreme Court issued an opinion today about a prison inmate who had a bunch of his stuff stolen from him by prison guards simply because he's a Muslim and they could do it with impunity. The ruling was that they were right, they could do it with impunity. Some statute about US customs was interpreted to mean that prison guards have immunity from any recourse against them or the government stemming from such thefts.

The whole thing is totally irrational, completely ignores any attempt to consider actual facts, and the opinion focuses more on commas than on actual meaning of language.

It's an example of the way the law works. The court just finds some rhetorical bullshit to lead them to the conclusion they want to reach. That's law. That's procedural justice. That's America.

In another example of the absurdity of legal thought in America, the DOJ submitted a brief to the Supreme Court on the current gun case being considered by the court where they argued that the Second Amendment defines an individual right but that the government must be able to ban hand gun ownership because if we don't allow that people will be allowed to run around on the streets with missile launchers. Or something like that. Just absurd.

Labels: , ,


Lifestyle and Political Blogs


Friday, September 21, 2007

Banks and the FBI

Somebody please tell me this is a joke.

Update:
I'm told this isn't a joke. I'm told that some banks in Las Vegas have a "no hats" policy. This is just insane.

Labels:


Lifestyle and Political Blogs


Friday, July 27, 2007

More prosecutors who should be in prison

You have a prescription for those drugs? That's not a defense for possession, at least not in Tampa. There was not even an accusation that the pills were intented for anything other than personal use.

Labels: ,


Lifestyle and Political Blogs


Thursday, July 19, 2007

New Mexico strikes a blow against secret police

I've always been bothered by the idea that it's okay for police to use force to hide the identity of undercover cops (doing things like breaking camaras).

Now a New Mexico court agrees with me.

This country does not need to provide special protections to secret police. If we can't do our policing openly then there's something wrong with whatever it is that the police are trying to accomplish.

Labels: , ,


Lifestyle and Political Blogs


Wednesday, July 18, 2007

The South Really Just Hasn't Changed

There really is two Americas. We should be sending more prosecutors to prison, there's no reason for a modern country to tolerate this kind of government behavior.

Labels: , ,


Lifestyle and Political Blogs


Monday, July 16, 2007

Immigrants aren't criminals

Illegal immigrants are usually hot criminals. Not all violations of law are violations of criminal law, not all law is criminal law.

But it's the policy of the US government to treat them as criminals even when they are not criminals and are not charged with a crime.

There is something very wrong with he kind of people we've become in America. Really wrong.

Labels: ,


Lifestyle and Political Blogs


Friday, July 13, 2007

More on beer and ID

A few weeks ago I made a short comment on an article in the blog at the Knoxville News about merchants collecting DL scans when you bought beer.

I think that's really bad stuff. In a later blog entry where they collected a few comments by other bloggers like me a commenter said
Posted by: Michael Silence at July 2, 2007 09:31 AM

A U.S. passport is a valid photo ID. It doesn't have a barcode, nor does it have your address on it.

While that's true, it's not really helpful.
A state does not have to accept ID from elsewhere to verify age to sell booze. They have to accept another state's DL for purposes of checking authorization to drive, or a passport for purposes of allowing you on an airplane. But for purposes of buying beer each state can require that you have an ID issued by them.

Beer is special. And I guess beer bought at a 7/11 is very special.

Labels:


Lifestyle and Political Blogs


Friday, July 06, 2007

Neuter that dog

... or go to jail.

I think more people should neuter their pets, but I'm not so sure that we need to be sending pet owners to jail for not doing it.

Labels:


Lifestyle and Political Blogs


Tuesday, July 03, 2007

Driving while feeling bad

This is just insane.

From nj.com: The severe symptoms of a hangover -- piercing headaches, body aches, dry mouth and upset stomach -- should no longer be your only concern after a night of drinking in New Jersey. Now there is the law.

In a ruling that expands the legal meaning of "under the influence," a state appeals court Thursday ruled a hangover is also an impairment -- whether it's from drinking alcohol, taking cocaine or other substances.

The judges, in a 3-0 decision, ruled a Cape May County driver, who had taken cocaine but was not intoxicated when police stopped him, was still a danger to other drivers. While the cocaine was no longer active it was the "proximate cause of his impaired behavior," the judges found.
Simply: drivers who are hung over from using cocaine can be considered impaired even if the drug is no longer in their systems.

If driving with a headache that is induced by having drank to much, or taken cocaine yesterday when is it going to become a crime to simply drive with a headache? You're just as impaired if the headache is caused by bright sun as you are if it was caused by a hangover.

Does New Jersey have some kind of bar exam requirement that requires lawyers be insane?

Labels: ,


Lifestyle and Political Blogs


Sunday, July 01, 2007

What fourth amendment?

Now, you'll be subject to a police warrant check whenever you buy a six-pack. You better make sure that traffic ticket is paid.

Hat tip to Instapundit.

Burlymike.com
isn't real impressed by this either.

Labels:


Lifestyle and Political Blogs


pregnant criminals

Lawyers, guns, and money has an interesting post about the absurdity of prosecuting pregnant women for things like drug delivery to a fetus. Or even dumber prosecutions.
A good example is the punishment of pregnant women. My common sense indicates that prosecuting pregnant women for anything and everything they do during pregnancy that might -- or might not -- affect fetal development is a bad idea. Take, by way of example, the case of Theresa Hernandez. Ms. Hernandez, who lives in Oklahoma, is being tried for first degree murder for suffering a stillbirth at 32 weeks of pregnancy. The prosecution is based on a "highly questionable" (according to NAPW) claim that Ms. Hernandez's use of illicit drugs during her pregnancy caused the pregnancy loss.

Labels:


Lifestyle and Political Blogs


Sunday, June 24, 2007

Felony Redneck

Feeding Gin to a baby is not exactly good parenting, it certianly qualifies as really stupid.

It might even be criminal. But does everything stupid have to be a felony? Is there some kind of limit on how many people we want to put in prison for stupid behavior?

Labels: , , ,


Lifestyle and Political Blogs


Wednesday, June 13, 2007

Watch those pants

This kind of thing just makes being an American embarrassing
Mayor Carol Broussard said he would sign an ordinance the town council approved this week setting penalties of up to six months in jail and a $500 fine for being caught in pants that show undergarments or certain parts of the body.


Broussard said he has nothing against saggy pants but thinks people who wear them should use discretion. "It's gotten way out of hand out here," he said.


Albert Roy, the councilman who introduced the ordinance, said he thought the fine was a little steep and should be more in the $25 range, but he still favored the measure.



"I don't know if it will do any good, but it won't hurt," Roy said. "It's obvious, and anybody with common sense can see your parts when you wear sagging pants."

Labels:


Lifestyle and Political Blogs


Scratching while driving

I'm watching some idiot segment on MSNBC about some woman in Utah who was kille in a car accident caused by a driver who was sending a text message while driving.

Her momma wants a law outlawing texting while driving.

Maybe we should pass a law against scratching your ass while driving.

Idiots.

Labels:


Lifestyle and Political Blogs