Friday, May 01, 2009

confession

It only took almost 7 years of enhanced interregation to get this guy to confess.

Labels:


Lifestyle and Political Blogs


Wednesday, February 13, 2008

Is Torture a Good Idea?

There are a lot of reason that torture is a bad idea, no matter what Scalia thinks. Here's one reason
Another point: Everyone forgets that the Iranian revolution of 1978-1979 was the revolution against torture. When the Shah criticized Khomayni as a blackrobed Islamic medieval throwback, Khomayni replied, look who is talking, the man who tortures. This was powerful rhetoric for recruiting people, then as it is now. People joined the revolutionary opposition because of the Shah’s brutality, and they remembered who installed him. If anyone wants to know why Iranians hated the US so, all they have to do is ask what America’s role was in promoting torture in Iran. Torture not only shaped the revolution, it was the factor that has deeply poisoned the relationship of Iran with the West. So why trust the West again? And the Iranian leadership doesn’t.

Labels:


Lifestyle and Political Blogs


Saturday, January 05, 2008

Torture


Lifestyle and Political Blogs


Thursday, August 23, 2007

Torture

This is an old post from AlterNet that I'd intended to make a post about but never got around to it.

I think the issue of the American government committing torture to be a very important one, one that shouldn't be swept under the rug.

It's not about the bad guys. It's about us. What the hell kind of people are we?

Labels:


Lifestyle and Political Blogs


Saturday, June 02, 2007

They hate us for our freedoms

From Balkinization
Last fall, Majid Khan was at the center of an amazing piece of litigation: his lawyers filed a motion demanding that they be allowed to see him, and the government opposed it, claiming that the meeting might lead to the disclosure of classified methods of acquiring information. In other words, Majid Khan might tell his lawyers what his captors did to him.


Read the post.

In another post he points out that torture doesn't become something else just because we call it "red turtle" or whatever phrase the Republican candidates for President prefer.

Labels: , , , ,


Lifestyle and Political Blogs


Thursday, May 17, 2007

The Republican position on torture

Ann Althouse comments on the Rudy/McCain differences in attitude about the use of torture by the US government.

My comment on her post is

There is only one reason to torture -- to appear tough.

Torture does not make anyone safe, it does not help you acquire usable information.

Rudy, like Tenet did recently in his book, seems to think that it's not really torture if you make up some mealy-mouthed term to use instead of the word torture.

He thinks that makes him a tough guy. I think it makes him a coward. If you want to torture people at least be straight up about it -- tell us that's what you want to do and let's talk about what value that kind of behavior is.

In the "ticking bomb" storyline that the Fox moderator took from a "24" plotline to use in his debate question, there's a presumption that using torture actually will provide you with usable information. The presumption is that so long as you are sure the victim of your torture has the information you seek that the torture will get it out of him.

That presumption is nothing but bullshit. People being tortured will never tell you the truth, they will always tell you want you want to hear. The only way you can be sure that they'll tell you the truth is if you already know the truth and they're aware of that. They will play to whatever they perceive your bias to be, whatever it takes to get you to stop.

Torture serves no purpose at all other than the creation of a facade of toughness, or to create terror in the minds of those who might be captured later. It's not an act of intelligence gathering, it's an act of terrorism.

Are the Republican candidates fighting a war against terror? Or is it a war of terror?

Labels: , , ,


Lifestyle and Political Blogs


Sunday, April 29, 2007

Tenet on 60 minutes

He's lying. Very simple, very obvious

He said nobody was tortured. He says we did "enhanced interrogations" and that when he gave the okay to do that it kept him awake nights. Huh? He also says he won't discuss whether the enhanced interrogations includes anything specific such as water boarding.

That's all such an obvious lie it's laughable. Of course we tortured people. Changing words doesn't change the deeds.

The other early lie was whether anyone died in interrogations. First he said, No. When quizzed further he qualified, "Not in the program you a and I are talking about right now". Which, of course means that somebody did die in enhanced interrogations, just not on the Thursday interregations.

They all lied to us then, they're all lying to us now.

Impeach all those sonsofbitches.

Labels: , , ,


Lifestyle and Political Blogs


Tuesday, February 20, 2007

Our New Tradition about Torture

The Balkinization blog has a timely essay about America's tradition of treating prisoners humanely. In particular the treatment of prisoner's of war. During the Revolutionary war the British treated American POWs terribly, a very, very high proportion of of them died from torture and starvation in British camps. In some cases the British just put American prisoners on ships and openly starved them in New York harbor.

We sure have changed.

Labels:


Lifestyle and Political Blogs