Monday, January 22, 2007

Why do they hate us?

Your typical right wing nutcase seems to cringe at the question "Why do they hate us?", tending to tag such a question as a hate America first approach.

Maynard, on Tammy Bruce's blog, finially explained why they tend to have such a knee-jerk reaction. They don't understand the question.

Such statements rest upon an implicit assumption that hatred is somehow, if not reasonable, at least rational. But that's utter nonsense. What did the Jews do to make the Nazis hate them? What did Abel do to make Cain hate him?

The answer to the question doesn't have to be about us. It's more likely about them. It's about how they think, not about what we've done. And, it's important to understand how our enemies think.

Lifestyle and Political Blogs


Blogger Karol said...

How, exactly, would it have helped the Jews to understand how the Nazis think? I guess it's just the typical leftwing nutcase response when there is conflict to focus on something else entirely, something unsolveable and irrelevant.

11:34 PM  
Blogger Gary Carson said...

I think most of the Jews in, for example, Warsaw, might have not sat around in the ghetto waiting to be rounded up if they had known what the German government was thinking.

Understanding the history and depth of the Sunni/Shia conflict might have helped us avoiding forming an Iraqi government that was a sure thing to cause a civil war

I think understanding the Muslim objections to our support of Isreal might have caused the American voter to ignore the idiots who kept saying "they hate us for our freedom". That might have lead to some effective foriegn policy the last couple of years.

Maybe not though. I just always leaned towards the idea that it's helpful to know what the hell is going on before jumping in the briar patch.

Was it a leftwing nutcase who focused on Iraq when he had conflict with Al Quada?

5:24 AM  
Blogger Karol said...

I was making fun of your "typical rightwing nutcase" line.

Your comment about Israel implies that they hate us because we support the only democracy in the region. But how does the average Saudi find himself affected by American policy on Israel? He doesn't.

They do hate us for our freedom--they hate Israelis for their freedom too.

11:47 PM  
Blogger Karol said...

This comment has been removed by the author.

11:48 PM  
Blogger Karol said...

Whoops, didn't mean to post twice.

Oh, one final thought: Jews in Warsaw, for example, had nowhere to go. Most countries, the US included, were not accepting them in.

11:50 PM  

Post a Comment

Links to this post:

Create a Link

<< Home